Where you sleep in Santorini decides what kind of trip you get. Stay on the caldera side — Oia, Imerovigli, Fira — and every morning starts with the Aegean spread out below your terrace and every evening ends with a sunset that people travel across the world to see. Stay on the beach side — Kamari, Perissa, Akrotiri — and you’ll swim more, spend less, and sleep easier, trading the famous view for a fraction of the price.

There’s no wrong answer, only a right one for your trip. So instead of a list of fifty hotels, here are three stays we’ve actually vetted, one per budget, each in a village that earns its keep: a caldera-side splurge for the trip of a lifetime, a great-value favorite in the island’s lively capital, and a genuinely charming budget hideaway near the southern beaches.